Comments Submitted for the new Sainsbury’s development PA25/05709

Further to a ’Teams’ meeting with Sainsbury’s and their advisors on 23rd September, Falmouth Civic Society wish to object to the application in its current form.
While the principle of a new supermarket on the site and the provision of mixed housing on the existing site is supported, we have a number of concerns that should be addressed.
First, the position of the site is on a key gateway into Falmouth and Penryn and should have the highest quality of design to reflect the importance of the towns. The placing of a petrol station and car park are not worthy of the location. However, we recognise that Sainsburys may be unwilling to change the proposed layout in any significant way. In that case the only option is to ensure that the screening is effective. In the present proposal it is not.
We believe the provision of the petrol station is visually unacceptable. Falmouth Town Council have objected to the petrol station. Cornwall council should be discouraging further fossil fuel outlets having declared a Climate Emergency. Falmouth Civic Society also objects and believes there is no need for a petrol station at all. Falmouth and Penryn are adequately provided with petrol stations.  Falmouth and Penryn already have 4 (5 including Treluswell). There is no evidence that Falmouth and Penryn are under-provided. Other Cornwall towns manage with fewer petrol stations. 
St Austell has 4, Camborne/ Redruth have 3 (4 including Scorrier), Truro has 2 (3 including Playing Place) and these are all on more trafficked through routes than Falmouth/ Penryn. Plymouth has 15 but has 10 times the population of Falmouth/ Penryn.
At a time when fossil fuel travel is being supplanted with greener alternatives, a company such as Sainsbury’s should not be encouraging greater use of fossil fuels. It does nothing for Sainsbury’s green credentials. 
The area of the petrol station could be better used for several electric vehicle charging points, without the need for an ugly and obtrusive canopy or large underground storage tanks which would be a future environmental millstone. Electric vehicle charging points would also be a more cost-effective revenue stream in terms of construction costs and enhance Sainsbury’s environmental credentials in accentuating the positive.
The petrol station omission would allow this area to be better and more densely screened from the road with enhanced landscaping and planting as befits this gateway site to Falmouth and Penryn and to reflect and respect the award-winning landscaping for the current roundabout. 
Cornwall’s DPD housing delivery team made the following comment. ‘Delivery of a high-quality design is expected that positively responds to the area’s wider built, natural and historic environment. The scheme should positively address Falmouth Road, with particular focus on the design quality in
this location, as it represents a gateway to both Falmouth and Penryn.’ While this comment specifically related to future housing it is no less true for the supermarket application site.
We have expressed concerns over the detail of the inadequate fencing to the car park at the top of the ‘green’ retaining wall. The computer imaging shown in the Design statement and landscaping documentation is inadequate from a screening and Health and Safety viewpoint. A better and safer solution can be provided without detriment to the design.

Concerns have been expressed over the materials proposed for external steps particularly between the future housing site and the supermarket site. The proposed timber steps will be a serious Health and Safety hazard.
Further detail should be provided for the pedestrian/ cycle crossing point on Falmouth Road. Certainly, this is a necessary provision. 
Although we are aware the housing proposal is a reserved matter, like Cornwall’s housing delivery team, we are concerned that the design and layout should be of the best quality. There is a particular issue concerning the layout that we wish to flag, and this concerns the Dissenters and Jewish cemeteries, which together are a Scheduled Monument. Care and collaboration with key stakeholders should be made a condition of any planning consent, particularly the needs of accessing and maintaining the cemeteries. Another concern is that the access way to the Dissenters’ cemetery is just inside their boundary. As the housing allocation that surrounds
to the west is only outline at the moment, it is hard to determine how any development would abut that boundary wall. Again, this needs to be an important consideration in assessing this application, both from the practical point of view, and in relation to any harm poor design and layout might do the Scheduled Monument.
We feel that the new Sainsbury’s store could be an asset to Falmouth and Penryn, especially if the changes we have outlined are implemented in the final design.

Award for Mike Jenks' book on The Old Town Hall

A win for Falmouth Civic Society

Every year Gorsedh Kernow (Gorsedh of the Bards of Cornwall) recognises the best published work in Cornwall with a Holyer an Gof Publishers’ Award. The name means ‘Follower of The Smith’ and was the Bardic name of Redruth Publisher Leanoard Truran. The award was instigated in 1996 in memory of him.

There are 12 categories of this prestigious award, and the 2025 winner of the Category 6 (booklets) was our Chairman Mike Jenks for his book ‘The Old Town Hall, Falmouth’ published by our Society. You may remember that this was published to coincide with the blue plaque we erected on the Old Town Hall building at the top of High Street.

The awards ceremony at Kresen Kernow was on the 5th of July, and you can see all the winners, and pictures of the event on this link – https://gorsedhkernow.org.uk/holyer-an-gof-publishers-awards/

It was a splendid way to give some publicity to Falmouth Civic Society, and for anyone interested, the booklet is on sale at the Cornish Store, 11 Arwenack Street, and The Old Town Hall, 3 High Street.

Plans for the docks

Changes afoot at the Docks
A planning application (PA25/01598) has been submitted for a large-scale change at the
Docks. The application is a bit intimidating with 147 documents submitted, many of detailed
technical studies. And, at first sight the visualisations shown might seem alarming.
The aim of the proposal is to repair the dock’s infrastructure, which is in a poor condition, to
extend the Queens Wharf and add a new northern section, to create a new western wharf,
and to build a new strong deck to accommodate work on large floating platforms and
windmills for the floating offshore wind market (FLOW).
The changes will also increase the cruise and cargo capacity and allow larger cruise ships to
berth. The docks would be able to take two large (345m) cruise ships at one time.
On the simplified plan below, the new work is in blue, and the red shows some existing
structures to be demolished. The triangular structure is a floating platform, and the outline of
a large cruise ship can be seen alongside Queen’s Wharf.

As with any large change, there may be some disruption to local traffic, and some noise
during major construction works. Some dredging next to the new west wharf will be required

and the disposal of the dredged material might be by sea, or by road. Interestingly, there is a
desire to extend the railway into the docks, and this would only need some points for it to
happen.
Is it worth it? The answer must be yes. It would be a real boost to Falmouth’s economy, for
jobs and for tourism with more cruise and larger cruise ships visiting.
The ‘alarming’ visualisations show large yellow structures and huge windmills, supported by
a large crane, and will be seen from miles around. But none of this is permanent. These
structures will come and go, and far from causing ‘harm’ to the surroundings should be
exciting to watch as an ever-changing scene. Seeing large structures being erected and
taken out to sea would be a unique sight in the Southwest, and one not to be missed.
This is an initiative that should be welcomed and supported by our Civic Society.

Solverwp- WordPress Theme and Plugin